A ‘spoke in the wheels’ of India’s debt market? What the Supreme Court’s ruling in ECL Finance means for lenders’ protective rights

Authors: Mr. Ajay Shaw (Partner) and Mr. Soham Mookherjee (Associate Partner)

Why lenders ask for more than a promise to repay

When a business or a company borrows money, the return promised to a creditor is generally fixed. The creditor is paid back its money with interest, on an agreed timeline, and unlike a shareholder, does not generally share in the equity upside. Because it is paid before shareholders, it also takes less risk than an equity investor.

Hence, a lender’s main worry is the downside and whether it will be repaid and how quickly it can be repaid if things go wrong. Any probable default risk is priced in by lenders through an increase in lending rates while sanctioning the grant of debt.

An economy which upholds enforcement of lenders’ rights reduces default risk and lowers cost of capital. Such lenders’ rights also include the right to initiate insolvency proceedings in a timebound manner before substantial value erosion with lenders looking to play a pivotal role as part of the creditors’ committee in order to drive home a commercially acceptable solution. 

In India, recovering money through courts and tribunals can sometimes take years. Hence, lenders also seek special rights and protective rights to allow them to keep a close watch and step in if trouble or stress starts brewing. These rights provide better protection and leverage in negotiating settlements and their exits while navigating through an unpredictable resolution or recovery process.

Common examples of protective rights which allow a lender to steer a borrower away from troubled waters or to pull the plug early while there is still value left to salvage include:

  • Appointing a director or observer on the board of the borrower.
  • Routing of income through a lender controlled bank account (or escrow) so that timely debt servicing is always prioritized.
  • Consent/approval requirements before any change in asset-liability position of the borrower, any payment of dividend, any sale of assets or undertaking deals between group companies.
  • Inspection of books, and appointment of independent valuers and engineers to check project completion status.
  • Consent/approval rights for budgets and business plans and replacement of management if the business goes badly.

On October 27, 2026, the Supreme Court of India in the matter of ECL Finance Limited and Anr. v. Abhinav Mukherjee held that a wide set of protective rights can result in the lender being a ‘related party’ of the borrower. Such a classification has serious consequences for a lender if the borrower becomes insolvent.

Why being a ‘related party’ matters for a lender

When a company becomes insolvent under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), its unrelated financial creditors form the creditors’ committee which decides its fate including whether a resolution plan is acceptable, from whom, and on what terms.

The classification of a creditor as a ‘related party’ therefore matters greatly as a creditor who has been classified as such ceases to have any right of representation or participation or voting rights in the creditors’ committee. This essentially leads to the creditor or lender losing any say over settlements, resolution or liquidation. It is also highly unlikely that a resolution plan will make any substantial payments to related party creditors given that related parties are often insiders linked to the failure.

One limb of the definition of ‘related party’ under IBC in Section 5(24)(m)(i) covers anyone “who is associated with the corporate debtor on account of participation in policy making processes of the corporate debtor”. The question in this case was whether a third-party lender’s protective rights amount to such participation.

What the Supreme Court decided

In this case, a real estate developer, Palm Developers, had guaranteed money raised by another company from a non-banking lender, ECL Finance. When Palm Developers went into insolvency, a homebuyer objected to ECL Finance sitting on its committee of creditors. The tribunals upheld the objection, and so did the Supreme Court. It made three key observations in its decision:

  • Control is not needed: A lender need not be in the driving seat. It is enough that it takes part in shaping the borrower’s policy.
  • Having the power is enough: What matters is whether the lender is in a position to exercise influence, not whether it actually did. The right to appoint a nominee director counts even if no nominee was ever appointed.
  • The documents are to be read together: The court looked at the loan and debenture documents, the company’s articles and even the agreements with homebuyers to assess the true relationship between the borrower and the creditor.

The rights that tipped the balance

The Supreme Court held that ECL Finance’s rights, taken together, gave it ‘all-pervasive control’ over the borrower’s business and real estate projects. The court found:

  • Board rights: ECL Finance could appoint nominee directors and observers, and its nominee could break board deadlocks. The court said the power to appoint was enough to tip the scales, even if no one was actually appointed.
  • Ringfencing of money: All project income went into an escrow account run only on the lender’s instructions. The court held that this went beyond a typical lender escrow, as all spending was dependent on approvals from the lender.
  • Budgets and timelines: All budgets, business plans and change in completion schedules required consent from the lender. The court treated this as taking part in policymaking and steering the business.
  • Sales and management: The lender could appoint the sales agent and held a power of attorney for execution and registration of sale deeds for the project units. It could also approve or reject proposals for change in management. These were held to be part of the ‘all-pervasive control’ available to ECL Finance.

The Supreme Court also added that if a related-party lender sells the debt to another person in bad faith in order to circumvent such ‘related party’ status, the buyer of the debt can also be kept off the creditors’ committee. Going forward, even assignment transactions that are commonplace as a mechanism for liquidity management between lenders will need to be thoroughly analysed to assess whether the assignee can also be treated as a related party creditor.

Why this matters beyond one case, and what happens next

Nominee directors, escrow accounts, budget approvals, inspection and consent rights are standard features of debt documents in India, used widely by lenders across the spectrum of banks, non-banking financial companies, housing finance companies, financial institutions and private credit funds alike. If such rights can turn a lender into a ‘related party’ during an insolvency or liquidation, many lenders across the board could find themselves locked out of the very process meant to help them recover their money.

That can have wide knock-on effects. Lenders may think twice before taking a defaulting borrower into insolvency, knowing they may have no say once it begins. Once a case is admitted, it is hard to reverse: a moratorium halts other recovery action, and every creditor is equally bound by its outcome. Lenders who feel more exposed are likely to charge more or lend less or both, especially in sectors such as real estate and infrastructure where tight oversight of project cash is the norm.

Unless there is legislative change to Section 5(24)(m) of the IBC which clearly excludes its application to protective contractual rights granted in a financing transaction, or the decision is overruled by a larger bench in a subsequent judgment, lenders will need to rethink how their rights are structured and find new ways to protect themselves.

The ruling rightly seeks to stop creditors who are insiders from steering a rescue during insolvency or liquidation. But it risks sweeping in ordinary lenders who are simply protecting their money, and putting a spoke in the wheels of the very credit market the IBC was designed to strengthen.

Disclaimer: This article represents our understanding and interpretation of the relevant laws as on the date hereof and is provided without expressing any opinion, advice, or recommendation. The interpretations set out herein are subject to change, and there can be no assurance that any regulator, authority, or judicial body will concur with or adopt a position consistent with our views expressed in this article. This article is furnished solely for academic and informational purposes and should not be construed as legal advice or relied upon for any purpose whatsoever.