Authors: Mr. Ajay Shaw (Partner) and Mr. Soham Mookherjee (Associate Partner)
It brought about a complete shift in approach from the previous legislative framework’s ‘debtor-in-possession’ model to a ‘creditor-in-control’ model, thereby bringing about necessary behavioural changes amongst borrowers and resulting in effective, time-bound resolution in several insolvency cases.
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”) was one of the key reforms of the last decade. It was introduced to consolidate and amend the laws relating to the reorganisation and insolvency resolution of corporates and individuals in a time-bound manner, to maximise value, and to balance the interests of all stakeholders. The IBC’s impact was immediate, and it has changed how businesses are conducted. It brought about a complete shift in approach from the previous legislative framework’s ‘debtor-in-possession’ model to a ‘creditor-in-control’ model, thereby bringing about necessary behavioural changes amongst borrowers and resulting in effective, time-bound resolution in several insolvency cases. In this article, we will analyse some key features of the IBC’s journey and the key challenges that remain.
The judiciary prevented the IBC from being stonewalled: From the outset, the courts have dealt firmly with challenges to provisions of the IBC in various situations. In Innoventive Industries Limited v. ICICI Bank and Anr. (Civil Appeal Nos. 8337-8338 of 2017), the Supreme Court gave the IBC its much-needed teeth by establishing the primacy of “default”, holding that the occurrence of a “default” was sufficient to commence IBC proceedings, and by clearly recognising the IBC’s overriding effect over other enactments inconsistent with it. In Swiss Ribbons Private Limited v. Union of India (Writ Petition (Civil) No. 99 of 2018), the Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the IBC and reinforced its core objectives of resolution, revival, value maximisation, and balancing stakeholder interests.
Landmark judicial developments to support implementation of the IBC: In various judgments, the Supreme Court has propounded principles that have facilitated the smooth implementation of the IBC. In the matter of Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Limited v. Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors. (Civil Appeal Nos. 8766-67 of 2019), followed by the matter of K. Sashidhar v. Indian Overseas Bank & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 10673 of 2018), the Supreme Court upheld the “commercial wisdom of the COC” in approving a resolution plan, and confined interference with the COC’s decision to the grounds specifically set out under Section 31(1) read with Section 30(2) of the IBC by the NCLT and by the NCLAT under Section 61(3) of the IBC, without questioning the commercial wisdom or judgment of the creditors. In the matter of Ghanashyam Mishra and Sons Private Limited v. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited (Civil Appeal No. 8129 of 2019), the Supreme Court firmly established the “clean slate” principle. This decision provided certainty to successful resolution applicants by holding that, once a resolution plan is approved, all claims not forming part of the approved plan stand extinguished. For investors acquiring distressed companies, this judgment was critical because it eliminated the risk of unknown historical liabilities emerging after the acquisition and allowed resolution applicants to start the turnaround journey with a ‘clean slate’.
Shift from “debtor in possession” to “creditor in control” and improvement in credit discipline: This was a paradigm shift, as promoters and owners of businesses had earlier never contemplated a situation where their business could be taken over by creditors and supervised by the resolution professional for the purposes of resolution and reorganisation. This important aspect of the IBC, which comes into effect upon admission of a business into insolvency, has led to tremendous behavioural change among business owners, fostering credit discipline. Data and statistics show that many insolvency proceedings are settled after filing or withdrawn under Section 12A of the IBC once proceedings commence, largely because owners fear losing control of the business. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (“IBBI”) reports that over 30,000 cases (INR 14 lakh crore) have been successfully resolved at the pre-admission stage through withdrawals, and around 2,763 admitted insolvency proceedings have been closed by withdrawal or settlement after commencement. Thus, the IBC has significantly altered borrower behaviour, demonstrating the IBC’s deterrent effect on owners of business.
IBC has evolved as the preferred legal tool to address default (financial and operational): A situation of financial default, in addition to the framework under IBC, can be addressed through informal resolution within the aegis of the RBI framework, recovery proceedings before the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT) and commercial courts, and security enforcement proceedings under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002. However, over the last decade, IBC has become the single most utilised legal framework for dealing with defaults not only by financial creditors but, in several instances, by corporate debtors. Importantly, operational creditors have also resorted to commencing insolvency proceedings under the IBC in cases of default on operational debt. Around 45% of admitted IBC proceedings have been initiated by operational creditors, with 3,546 operational creditor cases closed through settlements and withdrawals, thereby demonstrating that IBC has become the preferred route for local businesses and operational creditors dealing with defaults under their contracts for supply of goods and performance of services as well.
Development of Insolvency Ecosystem: The ecosystem created under the IBC has been instrumental in the successful implementation of the IBC. The IBBI, responsible for framing rules and regulations under the IBC and overseeing the performance of insolvency professionals and registered valuers, has helped ensure overall oversight in the implementation of the IBC. NCLT across the country, with several benches, and the NCLAT, with a bench in Delhi and another in Chennai, have been at the centre of insolvency proceedings. Insolvency Professionals have been key players in insolvency and liquidation proceedings, as they are responsible for driving a successful resolution or liquidation of the business and for preventing value erosion of businesses, as the case may be, under the supervision of the creditors. Information utilities, acting as repositories of critical financial information, help expedite the admission of insolvency proceedings, where filings with such information utilities are prima facie evidence of the existence of a default. Registered valuers registered with IBBI play a significant role in insolvency and liquidation situations by assessing value and potential for better realisation, thereby assisting creditors in making the right call at the right time.
Significant Legislative Amendments from time to time: The Parliament of India has also played a crucial role in ironing out issues that have arisen in the implementation of IBC by enacting necessary legislative changes. Over the past decade, IBC has evolved through several important amendments, including: recognition of homebuyers as financial creditors; introduction of withdrawal of CIRP under Section 12A; introduction of Section 32A granting immunity to successful acquirers from past offences of the corporate debtor; a special insolvency framework for Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) through the pre-packaged insolvency resolution process (PPIRP); and strengthening of information utilities and creditor rights. Most recently, the issues that arose on account of the matter of Vidarbha Industries Power Limited v. Axis Bank Limited (Civil Appeal No. 4633 of 2021) with respect to admission into insolvency, and the matter of State Tax Officer v. Rainbow Papers Limited (Civil Appeal Nos. 1661 and 2568 of 2020) on the treatment of indirect tax dues as secured credit, were all addressed in the most recent amendments to the IBC in 2026.
Key Challenges that Remain: The IBC requires closure of proceedings within an outer time limit of 330 days, which includes time spent in litigation. However, the IBBI reports that, in practice, this timeline is extended to an average of 633 days due to prolonged and varied challenges, including litigation, appeals and reviews by various stakeholders and erstwhile promoters, before different adjudicating authorities, and a backlog of cases. This remains the only ‘thorn in the side’ of an otherwise effective legislative framework and needs urgent redressal through increasing the number of adjudicating authority benches and further simplifying the filing and admission process under IBC with an endeavour to practically meet the timelines enshrined under the statute.
The IBC’s greatest achievement has been transforming India’s credit and borrowing culture, thereby helping the debt market and the economy grow and reducing the cost of capital for businesses. It has bolstered creditor rights, facilitated the resolution and revival of viable businesses, and enabled investors to invest in distressed assets. Undoubtedly, the introduction of the IBC has been one of the past decade’s key economic reforms.