From Representation to Reform: Building India’s Policy Interface

Authors: Mr. Anand Desai (Managing Partner) and Dr. Vinay Preet Singh (Partner)

Over the past decade, India has pursued an ambitious programme of regulatory simplification. What it has not yet reformed is the process by which regulation is made. Until consultation becomes an obligation rather than a courtesy, good reforms will continue to arrive alongside avoidable mistakes.

Over the past decade, India has pursued an ambitious programme of regulatory simplification. What it has not yet reformed is the process by which regulation is made. Until consultation becomes an obligation rather than a courtesy, good reforms will continue to arrive alongside avoidable mistakes.

The cost of not being heard

A business can spend years building a market, creating employment and committing capital, and then find its economics altered by a single notification, a circular or a fresh interpretation by a regulator. Compliance costs rise, permissions that were routine become uncertain, and projects that were viable on paper stall.

India has done a great deal to reduce this risk. The Jan Vishwas Act of 2023 began the decriminalisation of minor economic offences, and the Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Bill, passed by Parliament in April 2026, extended the exercise to 784 provisions across 79 central laws. GST procedures have been simplified, single-window systems have spread across the States, and draft rules are now routinely placed in the public domain.

Yet the scale of what remains is sobering. The Jailed for Doing Business study by the Observer Research Foundation and TeamLease RegTech counted 69,233 compliances applicable to Indian enterprises, of which 26,134 carried a possible term of imprisonment. A regulatory stock of that size was not designed. It accumulated, one well-intentioned rule at a time, largely without a systematic test of how each rule would operate in practice.

A consultation system without consequences

The gap between government and industry is rarely one of bad faith. It is a gap of information. Policymakers often lack granular evidence of how a measure works on the ground, and businesses often fail to present that evidence in a form a ministry can use.

The formal channel meant to close this gap is weak. The Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy of 2014 requires draft Bills to be published for at least thirty days, with an explanatory note on their purpose and likely impact. It is an executive policy, not law. In the Sixteenth Lok Sabha, only 44 of 186 Bills introduced were placed for public comment, and more than half of those did not receive the full thirty days. The record of the Seventeenth Lok Sabha was no better. In December 2025, the Government informed Parliament that the policy had never been evaluated and that no record of ministerial compliance was maintained.

Even where consultation does occur, it is largely one-directional. Stakeholders submit comments; they are seldom told which were accepted, which were rejected, and why. The policy does not extend at all to the far larger body of rules, regulations, notifications and circulars through which most businesses actually experience the State.

What credible advocacy requires

Public policy advocacy, properly understood, is the discipline of presenting a concern to the right public institution, in a structured and lawful manner, supported by evidence. It has three components.

The first is diagnosis. One must establish the precise legal source of the difficulty, whether a statutory provision, a delegated rule, an administrative practice or a conflict between departments, and distinguish what the law requires from what an officer merely prefers.

The second is identifying the right forum. A problem caused by a State inspection regime will not be solved by a submission to a central ministry, and a problem embedded in a statute will not be solved by a clarification.

The third is evidence. A representation that a rule is “burdensome” carries little weight. One that quantifies the compliance cost, the transition time required to upgrade plant, or the investment deferred, and proposes an alternative that preserves the regulatory objective, gives the decision-maker something to act on.

Advocacy does not displace litigation. Judicial review remains an essential safeguard against action that is arbitrary, ultra vires or unconstitutional. But many disputes need never reach a court. A licence delayed by unclear documentation requirements may be resolved by a clarification. A new standard imposed without notice may be made workable by a phased implementation schedule. Dialogue before dispute saves time for the enterprise, the regulator and the judiciary alike.

What good reform looks like

The Karnataka Industries (Facilitation) (Amendment) Act, 2026, which came into force on 4 September 2026, shows what follows when practical bottlenecks are taken seriously. It requires the State Nodal Agency to issue affidavit-based clearance certificates within 15 days for units in industrial areas and 20 days for units outside them, failing which the certificate is deemed approved. It prohibits departments from requiring an applicant to furnish any document already issued by, submitted to or held by a State body, and obliges them to obtain it electronically instead. It restricts inspections during the certificate’s validity to those approved by the Head of Department in consultation with the nodal agency.

Each of these provisions answers a complaint that enterprises have raised for years. Whether the Act succeeds will depend on implementation and on inter-departmental discipline. Its design, however, reflects the right principle: the burden of administrative inefficiency should fall on the administration, not on the applicant.

The Singapore lesson

Singapore is often cited for its outcomes. In 2024 it received 16.5 million international visitors and record tourism receipts of S$29.8 billion, in a sector that depends on the seamless coordination of licensing, immigration, aviation, transport and payments. The more instructive lesson, however, lies in its institutions.

Since 2000, Singapore’s Pro-Enterprise Panel, chaired by the Head of the Civil Service, has received business suggestions on rules that are outdated, duplicative or disproportionate. It has received more than 2,000 such suggestions, accepted more than half, and over 1,000 have led to changes in rules or regulations. The significance is not the numbers. It is that business feedback has a permanent address at the apex of the administration, and that the administration is expected to respond.

Five changes worth making

If India is to convert a decade of reform into a durable system, five changes merit serious consideration.

First, give consultation the force of law. The thirty-day consultation requirement should be placed on a statutory footing and extended to subordinate legislation and to significant circulars of sectoral regulators. Where a ministry dispenses with consultation, its reasons should be published, not merely recorded.

Second, require a reasoned response. Every ministry and regulator that consults should publish a statement of the principal comments received and the reasons for accepting or rejecting them. Some regulators already do so in part; the practice should be universal.

Third, measure before and after. Significant regulatory measures should be accompanied by a regulatory impact assessment and should carry a review clause requiring evaluation within a fixed period, typically three to five years. A rule that cannot demonstrate its value at review should lapse or be revised.

Fourth, create a standing feedback institution. A Pro-Enterprise Panel at the Centre, located in the Cabinet Secretariat or with DPIIT, and counterparts in each State, would give enterprises a single channel for raising rule-level problems, with published timelines for response. DPIIT’s Business Reform Action Plan already benchmarks States on implementation; a permanent feedback institution would complete that architecture.

Fifth, make advocacy transparent. India has no framework for disclosing engagement between business and government. A simple public register of formal representations and meetings on regulatory matters would protect honest advocates, deter improper influence and strengthen public confidence in the process.

Ethics and responsibility

The legitimacy of policy advocacy depends on its distance from lobbying for private favour. Advocates must present verified information, disclose material qualifications, distinguish clearly between a legal entitlement and a policy request, and respect pending proceedings and the independence of statutory decision-makers.

Industry, for its part, must engage on principle and not only on profit. A submission that seeks only exemption will be treated accordingly. A submission that accepts the objective of a measure, such as a tighter environmental standard, and proposes a credible path to achieve it at lower cost, is one that serves both the enterprise and the public. Industry associations, in particular, should invest in the research capacity to make such submissions as a matter of course.

Conclusion

The ambition of Viksit Bharat will not be achieved by announcements. It will be achieved by rules that work, which requires that those who make the rules hear, in a disciplined and transparent form, from those who must live by them. India has demonstrated, from the Jan Vishwas reforms to Karnataka’s facilitation law, that it can correct regulation after the event. The next task is to build a system that gets regulation right before the event. That is not a concession to business. It is a condition of good governance.

Disclaimer: This article represents our understanding and interpretation of the relevant laws as on the date hereof and is provided without expressing any opinion, advice, or recommendation. The interpretations set out herein are subject to change, and there can be no assurance that any regulator, authority, or judicial body will concur with or adopt a position consistent with our views expressed in this article. This article is furnished solely for academic and informational purposes and should not be construed as legal advice or relied upon for any purpose whatsoever.